Write protected DVD-RAM

I have aquired a new laptop recently and have come up against a weird
problem.

The laptop (HP DV6000) is equipped with an optical drive that is supposed to
read and write DVD-RAM discs. I have a few of these so I decided to use
one to store my digital photos on. However when I try, I get an error
message that the disc is write protected. If I try to reformat the disc, I
get a similar message telling me the disc is write protected.

What gives? How do I remove the write protection from the disc?

Paul
Mon Jun 16 01:39:56 PDT 2008

Walter Wall wrote:
> I have aquired a new laptop recently and have come up against a weird
> problem.
>
> The laptop (HP DV6000) is equipped with an optical drive that is supposed to
> read and write DVD-RAM discs. I have a few of these so I decided to use
> one to store my digital photos on. However when I try, I get an error
> message that the disc is write protected. If I try to reformat the disc, I
> get a similar message telling me the disc is write protected.
>
> What gives? How do I remove the write protection from the disc?
>
>

There is mention of a write protect tab here.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dvdram

And here, is mention of a setting in Windows.
Untick "Enable CD recording on this drive".

http://www.wibble.co.uk/DVD-RAM/index.php

Paul

M
Mon Jun 16 01:54:00 PDT 2008


"Paul" <nospam@needed.com> wrote in message news:g358mq$3fa$2@aioe.org...
> Walter Wall wrote:
>> I have aquired a new laptop recently and have come up against a weird
>> problem.
>>
>> The laptop (HP DV6000) is equipped with an optical drive that is supposed
>> to read and write DVD-RAM discs. I have a few of these so I decided to
>> use one to store my digital photos on. However when I try, I get an
>> error message that the disc is write protected. If I try to reformat the
>> disc, I get a similar message telling me the disc is write protected.
>>
>> What gives? How do I remove the write protection from the disc?
>
> There is mention of a write protect tab here.
>
> http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dvdram
>

That is only present on DVD-RAM discs held in cartridges. Most current
computer drives cannot accept cartridge DVD-RAM discs.

> And here, is mention of a setting in Windows.
> Untick "Enable CD recording on this drive".
>
> http://www.wibble.co.uk/DVD-RAM/index.php
>

It shouldn't be necessary to untick this, but it some times can help (but
not on this occasion).

M
Mon Jun 16 02:21:48 PDT 2008


"Walter Wall" <wall@privacy.net> wrote in message
news:48561fbf_1@glkas0286.greenlnk.net...
>I have aquired a new laptop recently and have come up against a weird
>problem.
>
> The laptop (HP DV6000) is equipped with an optical drive that is supposed
> to read and write DVD-RAM discs. I have a few of these so I decided to
> use one to store my digital photos on. However when I try, I get an error
> message that the disc is write protected. If I try to reformat the disc,
> I get a similar message telling me the disc is write protected.
>
> What gives? How do I remove the write protection from the disc?

The one thing you haven't mentioned is the operating system, and your cross
posting to the windows XP hardware group has probably thrown a few people.
You are using Windows Vista.

Welcome to the world of Digital Rights Management (DRM) described as a 'best
selling product that nobody wants'.

The disc you are trying to write to was most probably formatted to FAT32 on
a PC other than the one you are trying to use it on, and not running Vista.
Most current DVD-RAM discs have provision for the CPRM (Copy Protection for
Recordable Media) DRM built in. Windows Vista has taken advantage of this
and supports it. Since your disc was formatted on another system, Vista
enforces DRM by disallowing the writing of any files which are recognised
media files (though the error message does not exactly give this away). If
you experiment, you will find that you can create folders and you can write
files such as .DOC, .XLS or any other non media files. But you can't write,
.WAV, .MP3, .JPG or any other recognised media file. I don't know what
happens if you change the extension, write the file and then change it
back - though this is hardly convenient if you are writing (say) 500 files.

As you have discovered, Vista won't allow a reformat of the disc in FAT32.
The workaround here is to reformat the disc in something like UDF 2.01,
which is the Vista default (If you insert a blank disk, Vista will helpfully
auto format it in UDF 2.01). If you really want FAT32, you should then be
able to reformat it back to FAT32. But be aware, this particular FAT32 is
not quite the same as the FAT32 from previous Windows versions as it
embraces the CPRM technology on the disc. You will now be able to write
your media files to the disc (unless they are tagged with CPRM data that
prohibits this). You can read the disc on previous systems, but writing
media files will be painfully slow and may well cause the disc to refuse to
accept media files under Vista again. Of course UDF 2.01 is not compatible
with any previous Windows incarnation.

You should be aware that Vista is a bit finicky with DVD-RAM formats, and it
can often happen that it refuses to reformat a FAT32 disc into any format
(the error messages are either that the disc is write protected, or that the
disc is in use or just a an error that the format failed to complete).

Basically, Microsoft have implimented DRM and totally inconvenienced those
that wish to use the optical drive for what it was intended.

GG
Mon Jun 16 02:45:06 PDT 2008

M.I.5¾ wrote:
> "Walter Wall" <wall@privacy.net> wrote in message
> news:48561fbf_1@glkas0286.greenlnk.net...
>> I have aquired a new laptop recently and have come up against a weird
>> problem.
>>
>> The laptop (HP DV6000) is equipped with an optical drive that is supposed
>> to read and write DVD-RAM discs. I have a few of these so I decided to
>> use one to store my digital photos on. However when I try, I get an error
>> message that the disc is write protected. If I try to reformat the disc,
>> I get a similar message telling me the disc is write protected.
>>
>> What gives? How do I remove the write protection from the disc?
>
> The one thing you haven't mentioned is the operating system, and your cross
> posting to the windows XP hardware group has probably thrown a few people.
> You are using Windows Vista.
>
> Welcome to the world of Digital Rights Management (DRM) described as a 'best
> selling product that nobody wants'.
>
> The disc you are trying to write to was most probably formatted to FAT32 on
> a PC other than the one you are trying to use it on, and not running Vista.
> Most current DVD-RAM discs have provision for the CPRM (Copy Protection for
> Recordable Media) DRM built in. Windows Vista has taken advantage of this
> and supports it. Since your disc was formatted on another system, Vista
> enforces DRM by disallowing the writing of any files which are recognised
> media files (though the error message does not exactly give this away). If
> you experiment, you will find that you can create folders and you can write
> files such as .DOC, .XLS or any other non media files. But you can't write,
> .WAV, .MP3, .JPG or any other recognised media file. I don't know what
> happens if you change the extension, write the file and then change it
> back - though this is hardly convenient if you are writing (say) 500 files.
>
> As you have discovered, Vista won't allow a reformat of the disc in FAT32.
> The workaround here is to reformat the disc in something like UDF 2.01,
> which is the Vista default (If you insert a blank disk, Vista will helpfully
> auto format it in UDF 2.01). If you really want FAT32, you should then be
> able to reformat it back to FAT32. But be aware, this particular FAT32 is
> not quite the same as the FAT32 from previous Windows versions as it
> embraces the CPRM technology on the disc. You will now be able to write
> your media files to the disc (unless they are tagged with CPRM data that
> prohibits this). You can read the disc on previous systems, but writing
> media files will be painfully slow and may well cause the disc to refuse to
> accept media files under Vista again. Of course UDF 2.01 is not compatible
> with any previous Windows incarnation.
>
> You should be aware that Vista is a bit finicky with DVD-RAM formats, and it
> can often happen that it refuses to reformat a FAT32 disc into any format
> (the error messages are either that the disc is write protected, or that the
> disc is in use or just a an error that the format failed to complete).
>
> Basically, Microsoft have implimented DRM and totally inconvenienced those
> that wish to use the optical drive for what it was intended.
>
>
>
Thanks for that. Yet another reason to skip the new improved Winders.

Walter
Mon Jun 16 03:45:27 PDT 2008


"M.I.5¾" <no.one@no.where.NO_SPAM.co.uk> wrote in message
news:48562c92$1_1@glkas0286.greenlnk.net...
>
> "Walter Wall" <wall@privacy.net> wrote in message
> news:48561fbf_1@glkas0286.greenlnk.net...
>>I have aquired a new laptop recently and have come up against a weird
>>problem.
>>
>> The laptop (HP DV6000) is equipped with an optical drive that is supposed
>> to read and write DVD-RAM discs. I have a few of these so I decided to
>> use one to store my digital photos on. However when I try, I get an
>> error message that the disc is write protected. If I try to reformat the
>> disc, I get a similar message telling me the disc is write protected.
>>
>> What gives? How do I remove the write protection from the disc?
>
> The one thing you haven't mentioned is the operating system, and your
> cross posting to the windows XP hardware group has probably thrown a few
> people. You are using Windows Vista.
>
> Welcome to the world of Digital Rights Management (DRM) described as a
> 'best selling product that nobody wants'.
>
> The disc you are trying to write to was most probably formatted to FAT32
> on a PC other than the one you are trying to use it on, and not running
> Vista. Most current DVD-RAM discs have provision for the CPRM (Copy
> Protection for Recordable Media) DRM built in. Windows Vista has taken
> advantage of this and supports it. Since your disc was formatted on
> another system, Vista enforces DRM by disallowing the writing of any files
> which are recognised media files (though the error message does not
> exactly give this away). If you experiment, you will find that you can
> create folders and you can write files such as .DOC, .XLS or any other non
> media files. But you can't write, .WAV, .MP3, .JPG or any other
> recognised media file. I don't know what happens if you change the
> extension, write the file and then change it back - though this is hardly
> convenient if you are writing (say) 500 files.
>
> As you have discovered, Vista won't allow a reformat of the disc in FAT32.
> The workaround here is to reformat the disc in something like UDF 2.01,
> which is the Vista default (If you insert a blank disk, Vista will
> helpfully auto format it in UDF 2.01). If you really want FAT32, you
> should then be able to reformat it back to FAT32. But be aware, this
> particular FAT32 is not quite the same as the FAT32 from previous Windows
> versions as it embraces the CPRM technology on the disc. You will now be
> able to write your media files to the disc (unless they are tagged with
> CPRM data that prohibits this). You can read the disc on previous
> systems, but writing media files will be painfully slow and may well cause
> the disc to refuse to accept media files under Vista again. Of course UDF
> 2.01 is not compatible with any previous Windows incarnation.
>
> You should be aware that Vista is a bit finicky with DVD-RAM formats, and
> it can often happen that it refuses to reformat a FAT32 disc into any
> format (the error messages are either that the disc is write protected, or
> that the disc is in use or just a an error that the format failed to
> complete).
>
> Basically, Microsoft have implimented DRM and totally inconvenienced those
> that wish to use the optical drive for what it was intended.
>

I was skeptical when I read that, but I tried formating in UDF and then back
to FAT32 and sure enough I can now save my piccys.

Unbelievable!