Owen
Fri Mar 28 20:55:56 PDT 2008
In article <ujmoTzRkIHA.5088@TK2MSFTNGP02.phx.gbl>, "Ruth Cheesley"
<newsgroup<at>suffolkcomputerservices<dot>co(dot)uk> says...
> Thank you for your advice - indeed i am inclined to come to the same
> conclusion - that or it's getting interference from somewhere - it's a
> catering firm so could be anything. Most likely suspect is very old
> cordless phones. Could also be the fact that it's a fairly old router ..
> plastic and tacky!
>
> The WAP is on top of the server, under a desk, however the laptops are both
> within 10m of the WAP - literally just a desk or two apart - so I wouldn't
> have thought it would be weak signal strength (they're both getting 5/5
> bars).
>
> I might try changing the wifi channel, and see if this makes any difference.
> I know it's picking up the GPO's ok as I've checked in the event viewer and
> I can see the certificate there. For now I've told them to use a wire when
> in the office, as I am away for a week, but I will want to resolve this asap
> on my return!
The example I gave of the old building with the thick walls ... the
wireless PC was showing 5 bars there. It was apparently a signal QUALITY
issue rather than STRENGTH. Cordless 2.4GHz phones can be deadly to
802.11b/g/n. In theory, microwave ovens as well, though I've never
personally seen that. But this is a catering firm ...
The firm's WAP placement is far from ideal. A catering firm sounds like
it might have a lot of metal around! In general, placing the WAP "as
high as possible" is a good rule of thumb. The best starting position
for adjustable omnidirectional antennas is usually perfectly vertical
since the dispersion pattern is a similar to a donut. If that's no help,
try one vertical and one horizontal.
What's the desk made of? If there's metal it could be causing problems.
Ditto being so close to a server. Commercial-grade servers (at least in
the U.S.) may not have to meet radio emissions regulations. For example,
I know some Dell servers are not approved for use in residential
environments for this reason.
As for channels ... download NetStumbler
(
http://www.netstumbler.com/downloads) which will display all detected
wireless networks, their channels, and signal strengths. I have solved a
couple of "failure to connect" problems with this, though mostly in
homes. At one client's townhouse I discovered 12(!) wireless networks on
the same channel he was using. Changed his WAP to a channel that was not
in use and several channels away from the in-use ones; problem solved.
You mentioned you have an older WAP. Many newer ones solve the channel
issue by having an "auto-select" setting. The WAP sniffs what channels
are in use and picks one that's not. This is dynamic: the WAP will
change channels on-the-fly if the channel it had been using starts
having interference problems.
From time to time I have also seen WAPs that SEEMED to be transmitting
OK but I still could not connect. In one case I had to explicitly
disable then enable the radio. Simply power-cycling the device did not
work! And I've seen a couple of cases where replacing the WAP was the
solution.
Good luck!
-- Owen Williams [SBS MVP]