Re: Problem on audio redirection over RDP by SergeiR
SergeiR
Fri Jun 30 11:02:37 CDT 2006
Hi,
It is quite expected, that a fat terminal server client ( like Windows XP
based) shall behave different, than a similar thin client ( like Windows CE
based). It is also expected, that the same thin client would work a bit
different, when connected to real terminal server, rather than to a limited
capability remote acess computer (like Windows XP).
I am not an expert in using RDP protocol with Windows XP - all our
experience is based on the real use of thin clients with true terminal
servers ( like Microsoft Windows 2000 Advanced server or Windows 2003
Server), where admin has more tools to tune up terminal server computing.
Even more tools and settings in Citrix MetaFrame terminal server, like
separate fully controllable data channel for audio.
SergeiR
"Raghav" <raghavendra.kalluraya@gmail.com> wrote in message
news:1151602898.143811.306140@i40g2000cwc.googlegroups.com...
> Thanks for the information. One of my observations is like, if I do RDP
> to my Windows XP machine through any other XP machine, the .mp3 is
> played with 44.1KHz. But if I do RDP from my WinCE machine, same .mp3
> is played with 8KHz. Also I tried Point to Point connection, still the
> result is same and I don't see much network traffic also. Please let me
> know if you have any suggestion on this.
>
> I suspect on RDP it doesn't request for device capabilitis from the wav
> driver. In my wav driver I support till 48KHz sampling rate. I feel, it
> straigt away opens the driver with 8KHz. which is also supported by wav
> Driver. But I am not sure that which factore makes RDP to use this
> sampling rate.
>
> Thanks,
> Raghav
>
>
>
> SergeiR wrote:
>> My guess in this case would be that RDP protocol doesn't allocate a fixed
>> bandwidth for your audio stream ( unlike iCA, which can set this
>> explicitly)
>> and so in your specific test case ( i.e. your network bandwidth in
>> general +
>> network load for that moment + capabilities of your XP machine as as a
>> server + the complexity of that specific .mp3 file) it became 8 ksamples.
>> Maybe your RDP connection settings are set to be modem-like rather than
>> LAN-like ?
>>
>> You could also experiment with measuring rates for different .mp3 files
>> as
>> well as try to use real terminal server as opposed to Windows XP to find
>> out
>> exact cause of this.
>>
>> On the general note, our company has many customers, who occasionally do
>> listen to .mps3 files in terminal server mode ( RDP or ICA), but in all
>> cases it is NOT the intent to match the quality of audio playback of the
>> same file being played locally. Further in the example I mentioned the
>> terminal server uses virtual sound card on its side (i.e. terminal server
>> has no sound card at all, but is capable to play audio in terminal server
>> mode), which may also be contributing to this.
>>
>> SergeiR
>